Judging quality
Grade on size, enamel gloss, serration retention along both edges, root completeness and tip integrity. Peruvian teeth often keep exceptional serrations; many large Carolina teeth have restored tips.
Fossil
The tooth of Otodus megalodon, the largest shark that ever lived, extinct around 3.6 million years ago. Teeth run from palm-sized to over seven inches; every extra half inch above five is a substantial jump in rarity and price.

Grade on size, enamel gloss, serration retention along both edges, root completeness and tip integrity. Peruvian teeth often keep exceptional serrations; many large Carolina teeth have restored tips.
Rinse only. Sudden drying can spall a waterlogged river tooth, so let fresh finds dry slowly.
Megalodon teeth turn up in Roman-era collections and were carried as protective amulets across the medieval Mediterranean.
Cultural history, recorded as tradition rather than as medical or scientific claim.
See it in person
Both rooms are open six days a week, and there is always someone happy to pull pieces out of the case so you can compare them under the light.